34 pizza restaurants in East Harlem
Best Pizza Restaurants in East Harlem (2026)
Top-rated pizza restaurants in East Harlem, Manhattan. Ranked by ratings, reviews, and vibe.
Take the Mood MatchEast Harlem is home to 34 rated pizza restaurants. Elpis Pizza & Gourmet Food leads the list with a 5.0-star rating across 26 reviews. Prices range from $ to $. Popular vibes include casual, neighborhood-gem, family-friendly.
1
Elpis Pizza & Gourmet Food
Chef Elpidio Escamilla, a culinary maestro with over 30 years of experience, is proud to introduce his latest venture to the food industry: *ELPIS Pizza & Gourmet Food*. This exciting new restaurant is officially open in the heart of Harlem, offering a fresh and innovative dining experience.
2
Supreme Eats Pizza And Pasta
Supreme Eats Pizza And Pasta offers delicious pizza and pasta dishes in New York, NY. We use fresh, high-quality ingredients to create classic and innovative flavors.
“Lunch Specials, Dinner Specials, Family Meals, Catering available. Dine in, takeout, or delivery available.”
3
Limon Pizzeria Halal
4
Armonie
Armonie Bistro offers a wide array of specialty Italian entrées & pizzas and is home to Armonie's famous vodka sauce. With options for parties/events, catering, and walk-in dining, Armonie Bistro truly offers a delicious gastronomic oasis for almost everyone who steps foot through its doors.
“Options for parties/events, catering, and walk-in dining. Beer and wine served. Catering orders: call 646-387-9204. Ask for Lonnie or Gus.”
5
109 Pizzeria
“5% off online only”
6
DA BIANCA PIZZERIA 🇮🇹
DA BIANCA PIZZERIA 🇮🇹 is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as pizza and italian, consistently well-reviewed, budget-friendly. Based on 10 reviews.
7
La Nostra Pizzeria
Our chefs specialize in authentic and delicious Pizza food. The staff at La Nostra Pizza is devoted to serving customers mouthwatering dishes that feature the highest quality ingredients available.
“Skip the line, skip the wait. Order online now and pick up your freshly made meal at your convenience.”
8
G&J's Pizzeria
G&J's Pizzeria is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, moderately priced. Based on 10 reviews.
9
Patsy's Pizzeria
Patsy's Pizzeria is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
“Reviewers note this is cash only.”
10
125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™
“www.125thstreetpizzaofharlem.com is no longer active on Slice.”
11
Milano Pizza Shop
Milano Pizza Shop is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as pizza and italian, consistently well-reviewed, moderately priced. Based on 10 reviews.
“Reviewers note this is cash only.”
12
Supreme Pizza NY
13
Famous Famiglia Pizzeria
Famous Famiglia Pizzeria is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as outdoor-focused, pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
“Multiple reviewers mention long waits, especially on weekends.”
14
La Amistad
“5% OFF Online only • Free Delivery, order on the app we prefer no crazy fees for you or us, Taco Tuesday Special - Only available Tuesday”
15
99¢ Mega Pizza
16
Dreamer's Pizza
Dreamer's Pizza is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
17
Sam’s Famous Pizzeria
Sam's famous Pizza was established in 1962. Our dough is made from scratch daily and our signature sauce is made from vine-ripened San Marzano Italian tomatoes.
“After 52 years, Sams famous is still an independently owned family business at only one location.”
18
Bardolino Pizza
From our Family to Yours! We Guarantee the Freshest & Highest Quality Food.
“Big Party to Cater Welcome at Bardolino we can Handle. Deliver in the area, anytime... Pick-up and Delivery options are available. Delivery Estimates: 40 mins | Pick Up Estimate: 20 mins”
19
Pizza 2 Go
Pizza 2 Go is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as pizza and italian, budget-friendly. Based on 10 reviews.
20
Five Star
Serving cheese steaks and pizza to New York, NY
21
Kennedy Chicken and Pizza
22
Pizza Hut
23
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus is a restaurant in East Harlem described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
24
Domino's Pizza
Pizza Delivery & Carryout, Pasta, Wings & More
“Mix and match: Choose any two for $6.99 each. Weeklong carryout: Carry out for just $7.99 each. You must ask for limited time offers. Prices, participation, delivery area, and charges may vary by store.”
25
Papa Johns Pizza
At Papa Johns Pizza in New York, NY, it's our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether its our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best New York pizza for any occasion.
“Call us for pizza delivery in New York or stop by 2119 1st Ave for carryout”
26
Domino's Pizza
Pizza Delivery & Carryout, Pasta, Wings & More
“You must ask for limited time offers. Prices, participation, delivery area, and charges may vary by store. Carryout only deals available. Mix and match options available. Choose Carryout or Delivery. Earn free Domino's every 2 orders with Rewards membership.”
27
Little Caesars
28
Sams Famous Pizza
29
Sss 99 Cents Mega Pizza
30
Elpis
31
G & J Pizzeria
32
5 Star Cheese Steak and Pizza
33
Milano's Pizzeria
34
Famous Pizza
Best Pizza Restaurants in Nearby Neighborhoods
More Restaurants in East Harlem
Looking beyond East Harlem? See the best pizza restaurants across all of Manhattan →
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza restaurants in East Harlem?
Moodap ranks 34 pizza restaurants in East Harlem, Manhattan based on ratings, reviews, and insider tips. Top picks include Elpis Pizza & Gourmet Food (5.0★). Take the Mood Match quiz to find the perfect one for your vibe.
How many pizza restaurants are in East Harlem?
There are 34 pizza restaurants currently listed in East Harlem on Moodap, with new spots added regularly.
Are pizza restaurants in East Harlem expensive?
East Harlem pizza restaurants range from $ to $. Use Moodap to filter by budget.
What's the highest rated pizza in East Harlem?
Elpis Pizza & Gourmet Food is one of the highest rated pizza restaurants in East Harlem, with a 5.0-star rating. See the full rankings above.
Find Your Perfect Spot in East Harlem
Tell us your mood and we'll match you to the ideal pizza spot in 25 seconds.
Take the Mood Match