3 pizza restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Best Pizza Restaurants in Carnegie Hill (2026)

Top-rated pizza restaurants in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan. Ranked by ratings, reviews, and vibe.

Carnegie Hill is home to 3 rated pizza restaurants. Italian Village Pizza & Restaurant leads the list with a 4.4-star rating across 519 reviews. Prices range from $ to $.

Italian Village Pizza & Restaurant

Italian Village Pizza & Restaurant is a restaurant in Carnegie Hill described by visitors as outdoor-focused, pizza and italian, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.

★ 4.4519 reviews$Indoor/Outdoor1494 1st Ave #1, New York, NY 10075

Little Caesars Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza is a restaurant in Carnegie Hill described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.

★ 4.0424 reviews$Indoor1936 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10029

Domino's Pizza

Pizza Delivery & Carryout, Pasta, Wings & More

★ 3.6281 reviews$Indoor1841 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028

“Mix and match Choose any two for $6.99 each. Weeklong carryout Carry out for just $7.99 each. You must ask for this limited time offer. Prices, participation, delivery area, and charges may vary by store. Carryout only. Excludes XL and Specialty Pizzas.”

Best Pizza Restaurants in Nearby Neighborhoods

Upper East Side Yorkville Lenox Hill East Harlem

More Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Looking beyond Carnegie Hill? See the best pizza restaurants across all of Manhattan →

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best pizza restaurants in Carnegie Hill?

Moodap ranks 3 pizza restaurants in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan based on ratings, reviews, and insider tips. Top picks include Italian Village Pizza & Restaurant (4.4★). Take the Mood Match quiz to find the perfect one for your vibe.

How many pizza restaurants are in Carnegie Hill?

There are 3 pizza restaurants currently listed in Carnegie Hill on Moodap, with new spots added regularly.

Are pizza restaurants in Carnegie Hill expensive?

Carnegie Hill pizza restaurants range from $ to $. Use Moodap to filter by budget.

What's the highest rated pizza in Carnegie Hill?

Italian Village Pizza & Restaurant is one of the highest rated pizza restaurants in Carnegie Hill, with a 4.4-star rating. See the full rankings above.

Find Your Perfect Spot in Carnegie Hill

Tell us your mood and we'll match you to the ideal pizza spot in 25 seconds.

Take the Mood Match