Best Pizza Cafes in Manhattan, NYC (2026)
Top-rated pizza cafes across 2 Manhattan neighborhoods. Ranked by ratings, reviews, and vibe.
Take the Mood MatchManhattan is home to 2+ rated pizza cafes spanning 2 neighborhoods. Bagels & Co. in Yorkville leads the pack with a 4.5-star rating, but standout spots can be found across Manhattan.
Prices range from $$ to $$, so there’s something for every budget. Whether you’re planning a date night, meeting up with friends, or exploring solo, this page covers the best pizza cafes in New York City — ranked by ratings, reviews, and real vibe data.
Yorkville1 spots
Lenox Hill1 spots
Explore Pizza Cafes by Neighborhood
Related Types of Cafes
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza cafes in NYC?
Moodap ranks the best pizza cafes across 2 Manhattan neighborhoods based on ratings, reviews, and vibe. Top-rated spots include Bagels & Co. in Yorkville (4.5★). Take the Mood Match quiz to find the perfect one for your mood in 25 seconds.
How many pizza cafes are in Manhattan?
Moodap has 2+ rated pizza cafes across Manhattan, spanning neighborhoods like Yorkville, Lenox Hill, and more.
Which neighborhood has the best pizza cafes?
Yorkville has the highest concentration of pizza cafes with 1+ spots, but great options are found across Manhattan. Use the Mood Match quiz to find the best one near you.
Best pizza cafes for a date night in NYC?
Many pizza cafes in Manhattan are perfect for date night. Take Moodap’s Mood Match quiz to find a spot that matches your exact vibe and budget.
Affordable pizza cafes in Manhattan?
Manhattan has pizza cafes at every price point, from $$ to $$. Browse the full list above sorted by rating, or take the Mood Match quiz to filter by budget.
Not sure which one?
Tell us your mood and we'll match you to the perfect pizza spot in 25 seconds.
Take the Mood Match