50 pizza restaurants in Upper West Side
Best Pizza Restaurants in Upper West Side (2026)
Top-rated pizza restaurants in Upper West Side, Manhattan. Ranked by ratings, reviews, and Moodap editor picks.
Take the Mood MatchUpper West Side is home to 50 rated pizza restaurants. Mama's TOO! Upper West Side leads the list with a 4.2-star rating across 2,650 reviews. Prices range from $ to $.
1
Mama's TOO! Upper West SideEditor's Pick
Legendary Upper West Side pizzeria from Frank Tuttolomondo serving NYC and Detroit-style square slices with gourmet toppings. Known for perfectly crunchy crusts, creative flavor combos, and sandwiches that rival the pizza. Tiny standing-room spot, always packed, always worth it.
2
Pizza CollectiveEditor's Pick
We use a long fermentation sourdough base, precisely 96h and 100% Italian flours. Our pizza can be considered of a unique kind!
“TUESDAY: ALL PASTAS AT 12$. Monday to Friday 12pm-3pm: Buy any 2 slices and get a plain cheese for $1”
3
Double Pie Pizza - Artisanal NY Pizza
Stone-baked artisanal pizza with naturally leavened 72-hour dough at this beloved Upper West Side family-owned establishment serving the community since 2011.
“Lunch specials offer two slices for $7 from 12 PM to 6 PM, Monday-Thursday get 50% off second pizza”
4
Mimi's Pizza (Broadway)
Mimi's Pizza (Broadway) is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, moderately priced. Based on 10 reviews.
5
Super Nice Pizza
6
Parla
Parla is an all-day neighborhood spot to gather round and let the good times roll. Situated on the Upper West Side of New York City, the menu celebrates our love of pizza and cocktails with a focus on simple, quality ingredients and warm hospitality.
“Reviewers recommend making a reservation. Considered a hidden gem by regulars.”
7
La Pizza Italia
8
Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West
9
Village Square Pizza - Upper West Side
We create gourmet New York style pizza in its finest form, using premium ingredients and a family recipe that has been used for generations.
“Get Free Delivery! Must eat right out of the oven for the best experience or heated up at home.”
10
Made In New York Pizza
Made In New York Pizza is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, high-energy atmosphere, consistently well-reviewed. Based on 10 reviews.
11
Traviata Pizza II
Traviata Pizza II is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
12
Marinara Pizza - Broadway
Marinara Pizza - Broadway is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
“MARINARA ROSLYN IS OPEN! WE CANT WAIT TO SEE YOU AT OUR NEWEST LOCATION! 5 Glen Cove Road, Greenvale, NY 11548, (516) 862-3343”
13
Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side
Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
14
Freddie & Pepper's
Back in 1978, the idea of introducing the best of pizza flavors to New York and eliciting the taste buds initiated a hallmark of excellence which was named Freddie and Peppers. Constant quality assurance, hygiene, taste enhancement, and improved ambiance is what that made Freddy and Pepper's one of its kind.
15
La Tinajita Pizzeria Cubana
Enjoy the best pizza West New York has to offer. Taste the best pizza in West New York.
“Pick up your pizza at La Tinajita Pizzeria Cubana with curbside pickup. Check out some of the regular deals offered at La Tinajita Pizzeria Cubana. 5% OFF Online only • Free Delivery. Order on the app we prefer no crazy fees for you or us.”
16
Dreamers Pizza II
WE MAKE THE BEST PIZZAS IN TOWN
17
Sal and Carmine Pizza
Thanks to the work of Sal & Carmine Pizza, the residents of New York, NY have been enjoying top-class experience for more than six decades. We are a family-friendly restaurant that opened in 1957 and has since become a household name for pizza in New York City, catering to one generation after the other with our renowned thin-crust pizzas.
“5% OFF Online only • Free Delivery. order on the app we prefer no crazy fees for you or us”
18
La Traviata Pizzeria
La Traviata Pizzeria is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, known for excellent service, consistently well-reviewed. Based on 10 reviews.
“order on the app we prefer no crazy fees for you or us”
19
Motorino Pizza
Motorino Pizza is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, relaxed atmosphere, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
20
Pizza Pete's
Enjoy the best pizza in New York like the locals do. Local residents have made Pizza Pete's one of the most popular in the area.
“10% OFF Online only • Free Delivery. Buy Any Two 13'' Pies & Get Free 6 Pack of Soda for $31.00. Buy Any Two 18'' Pies & Get Free 6 Pack of Soda for $38.00. You can get your pizza to go with curbside pickup from Pizza Pete's. Order on the app we prefer - no crazy fees for you or us.”
21
Salvatore's NY Pizza
Salvatore's NY Pizza is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, budget-friendly. Based on 10 reviews.
22
Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza is built on a foundation of fresh, natural ingredients, high-quality cheeses, and that legendary NYC water that gives our dough its signature taste. From Midtown to the West Village to the UWS, we're serving up NY-style pizza so irresistible, you'll find yourself coming back for more – and fast.
“Dine in, take out + delivery available at all locations”
23
Patsy's Pizzeria
Patsy's Pizzeria is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, premium. Based on 10 reviews.
“PRIVATE PARTIES / CATERING”
24
Marinara Pizza Upper West
Marinara Pizza Upper West is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
25
Saba's Pizza
Saba's Classic Thin Crust New York City Pizza.
“cholov yisroel - pas yisroel - שומר שבת”
26
La Vera
La Vera is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
27
Francesco's Pizza
Home of the olive oil crust pizza. Our dough is made fresh daily.
“order on the app we prefer no crazy fees for you or us”
28
Little Italy Pizza
At Little Italy Pizza, our story begins with family and tradition. My brother Salvatore learned the art of pizza-making at a young age, guided by the loving hands of our grandma.
29
94 Corner Cafe
“5% OFF Online only • Free Delivery, order on the app we prefer no crazy fees for you or us”
30
Famous Original Ray's Pizza
Serving New Yorkers authentic Italian pizza and classic dishes for over 50 years! We specialize in italian food with popular dishes like ray's famous special pizza , pepperoni pizza , cheese pizza , baked lasagna .
“Get 10% off when you order direct with code DIRECT10. Catering services available - contact via email or phone at any of our locations.”
31
Ranch Deli
Pizza Ranch Deli & Nightlife is a casual pizza and deli restaurant located in Manhattan Valley offering diverse menu items including custom pizzas, sandwiches, and salads.
“Arrive during off-peak hours as reservations are recommended during peak times; most dishes are under $15”
32
Cheesy Pizza
For over 40 years, we've been serving the Upper West Side with thin, cheesy slices and hearty Italian favorites.
“Our catering menu is packed with pizza, pasta, and Italian classics that make every gathering unforgettable.”
33
Peperino West Side
Peperino West Side is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
34
UNO Pizzeria & Grill
35
Famous Famiglia Pizzeria
Famous Famiglia Pizzeria is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, consistently well-reviewed. Based on 10 reviews.
36
Little Italy Pizza
Little Italy Pizza is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, budget-friendly. Based on 10 reviews.
37
Giovanni's Pizza
38
Made In New York Pizza
Made In New York Pizza is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian, budget-friendly. Based on 10 reviews.
39
Jet's Pizza
Jet's Pizza is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
40
Sogno Pizza
Sogno Pizza is a restaurant in Upper West Side described by visitors as pizza and italian. Based on 10 reviews.
41
Famous Famiglia
42
La Vera Pizza
43
Uno Chicago Grill
44
Sal & Carmine Pizza
45
Marinara Pizza
46
Famous Famiglia Pizzeria
47
Patsy's Pizzeria
48
Dbl Pie Pizza
49
Motorino
50
Marinara
Best Pizza Restaurants in Nearby Neighborhoods
More Restaurants in Upper West Side
Looking beyond Upper West Side? See the best pizza restaurants across all of Manhattan →
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza restaurants in Upper West Side?
Moodap ranks 50 pizza restaurants in Upper West Side, Manhattan based on ratings, reviews, and insider tips. Top picks include Mama's TOO! Upper West Side (4.2★). Take the Mood Match quiz to find the perfect one for your vibe.
How many pizza restaurants are in Upper West Side?
There are 50 pizza restaurants currently listed in Upper West Side on Moodap, with new spots added regularly.
Are pizza restaurants in Upper West Side expensive?
Upper West Side pizza restaurants range from $ to $. Use Moodap to filter by budget.
What's the highest rated pizza in Upper West Side?
Mama's TOO! Upper West Side is one of the highest rated pizza restaurants in Upper West Side, with a 4.2-star rating. See the full rankings above.
Find Your Perfect Spot in Upper West Side
Tell us your mood and we'll match you to the ideal pizza spot in 25 seconds.
Take the Mood Match