43 italian restaurants in Little Italy
Best Italian Restaurants in Little Italy (2026)
Top-rated italian restaurants in Little Italy, Manhattan. Ranked by ratings, reviews, and Moodap editor picks.
Take the Mood MatchLittle Italy is home to 43 rated italian restaurants. Torrisi leads the list with a 4.6-star rating across 851 reviews. Prices range from $$ to $$.
1
TorrisiEditor's Pick
Torrisi is a restaurant in Little Italy described by visitors as food-focused, italian and american, cozy interior. Based on 10 reviews.
“Reviewers recommend making a reservation.”
2
Osteria Barocca
Experience the essence of Italy at Osteria Barocca - where tradition meets culinary innovation. At Osteria Barocca, experience authentic Italian cuisine made with fresh, local ingredients in an elegant setting.
“Reserve ahead for weekends; call ahead to request outdoor seating or specific table locations”
3
Jose Luis Little Italy
4
Marcellino
5
Casa D'Angelo New York
Welcome to Casa D'Angelo, an authentic Italian restaurant in Little Italy, New York. Our family-owned restaurant has served delicious Italian cuisine for decades, earning us a reputation as one of the city's most beloved dining destinations.
“Private dining rooms are available for any occasion. Located at 146 Mulberry St, NY, between Hester & Grand Sts. Book your Casa D' Angelo reservation on Resy. Family Style Menu options available with minimum 8 people: Continental ($75/person), Deluxe ($105/person), Presidential ($165/person with wine and beer unlimited and open bar for 2 hours for mix drinks).”
6
L’Amore Restaurant
Nothing can be compared to Italian cuisine. It is always well-made, rich in taste and texture and guaranteed leaves you hungry for more.
“We are taking online reservations! We recommend making a reservation ahead of time. Book your table today! Come celebrate National Margarita day with us on February 22nd. We do catering for birthday parties, holiday parties, corporate events, wedding festivities and more.”
7
Zia Maria Little Italy
Zia Maria is a family-owned restaurant and pizzeria that offers authentic, homemade Italian food, bringing the fresh flavors of Italy to New York. We also offer a fully stocked top-shelf bar.
“FREE DELIVERY! *Up to 1 mile”
8
Piacere
Italian Restaurant, Pizzeria, and Wine Bar in Manhattan
“We offer take-out and delivery!”
9
Manero's of Mulberry
10
La Bella Vita
La Bella Vita is an authentic Italian restaurant in Little Italy serving traditional Italian cuisine made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Our menu features homemade pasta, classic Italian dishes, fresh seafood, and rich Italian sauces prepared using time-honored recipes.
“We are taking online reservations! We recommend making a reservation ahead of time. Book your table today! Call us at (212)-775-8484 or book a table through Open Table. Come celebrate National Margarita day with us on February 22nd. We do catering for birthday party, holiday party, corporate events, wedding festivities and more.”
11
Amici Ristorante
12
Buona Notte
13
Little Italy
14
Italian Food Center
Italian Food Center is a restaurant in Little Italy described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, high-energy atmosphere. Based on 10 reviews.
“Reserve ahead for dinner, especially on weekends; expect peak wait times 7-9pm”
15
Sofia's of Little Italy
A trendy Italian restaurant & bar located at 143 Mulberry Street in the heart of historical Little Italy NYC. Handmade Lasagna, Ravioli, Manicotti, Fettuccini with fresh-made pizza and a full seating bar with happy hour specials make Sofias a must-visit.
“FREE DELIVERY! *Up to 2 miles, on orders above $30. Under new management effective December 1, 2021 from Chef Andrea.”
16
Lunella
17
La Mela
Our family owned and operated restaurant welcomes you with a menu that is a celebration of traditional Italian flavors, crafted from time-honored family recipes passed down through generations.
“Large party events can be held in four party rooms. Wine, beer + full bar available.”
18
Benito One
19
Da Gennaro
Da Gennaro welcomes you to enjoy the finest and freshest home cooked Italian food available outside your grandmothers kitchen. The warm and inviting atmosphere, which is complimented by the rustic Italian decor, makes this the place to celebrate any special occasion, romantic dinner, or even a simple home cooked Italian meal.
“We are open for breakfast, lunch, brunch and dinner all year around. Sister restaurant Gelso & Grand is home to a rustic and elegant private dining space and full bar that can host upwards of 100 guests. We can tailor an event to your specific needs with use of our projector, DJ equipment and independent A/V.”
20
Il Cortile
IL Cortile Ristorante has been family owned and operated since 1975. IL Cortile is dedicated to delivering the finest Italian cuisine with one of the most innovative and interesting menus in New York City.
“Great for intimate or large parties for lunch or dinner being served by professional old school waiters in the heart of Little Italy, NYC.”
21
Gelso & Grand
22
Paesano of Mulberry Street
Family-owned and operated for generations, Paesano of Mulberry Street has been serving authentic Italian cuisine on historic Mulberry Street since 1961.
“Lunch specials available daily from 11am to 4pm. Reservations are accepted by phone and online. Guests are encouraged to make reservations, especially during evenings, weekends, and peak tourist seasons. Ask for the Trio Pasta as an off-menu favorite.”
23
Puglia
“DM WITH RESERVATION REQUESTS (FB or IG) OR CALL 212-966-6006. Live music every night!”
24
Original Vincent's
25
Da Nico
Da Nico Ristorante has been family owned and operated since its foundation in 1993. A staple in the New York community, we have served countless native New Yorker's including the Yankees and former Mayor Giuliani.
“they had given us the wrong drinks and they had no problem switching them out for the correct ones free of charge. they regalan un postre al pagar la cuenta”
26
Parm Mulberry Street
Since the original location of Parm opened in New York Citys Little Italy in 2011, the restaurant's takes on Italian-American soul food have reached iconic status. The goal is to make the best versions of these recognizable dishes while remaining faithful to their history—and to serve them in a fun, familial environment.
“Parm catering requires a minimum of 48 hours for ALL catering orders. For next day requests or same-day orders, please email [emailprotected] and we will do our best to accommodate your order. Pick up orders must be placed 48 hours in advance.”
27
Local 92
At Local92 in Soho, we believe that dining is more than just a meal, it's an experience. With a commitment to using the freshest ingredients and supporting local farmers, we craft every dish with care and creativity.
“Weekends at Local92 are now even more exciting! Join us for live DJ performances, setting the perfect vibe, alongside our special happy hour deals. For Private Events Message @local92NYC”
28
Il Piccolo Bufalo
29
Casa Bella
Join us for lunch and dinner, seven days a week, and enjoy classic Italian specialties—from handmade pastas to traditional seafood and meat dishes—prepared with the freshest ingredients and a passion for true Italian hospitality.
“Casa Bella offers a newly renovated private dining space perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, corporate gatherings, and family celebrations.”
30
Grotta Azzurra
Grotta Azzurra, founded in 1908, is a legendary Italian restaurant in NYC's Little Italy. Named after the famous blue grotto in Capri, it became a favorite of stars like Sinatra and De Niro.
“We can accommodate private parties of almost any size in our restaurant. Our warm and welcoming Wine Cellar Room creates a casual atmosphere, while our staff delivers the best of food, drink and Italian hospitality for your seated event for up to 60 guests or your standing events for up to 90 guests.”
31
Luna Ristorante
Luna Ristorante is a restaurant in Little Italy described by visitors as italian and seafood, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
32
La Nonna
33
Caffe Napoli
Established by Anna Silvestri and Family in 1972, Caffe Napoli introduced the sidewalk cafe in Little Italy. What started as a modest cafe serving only coffee and pastry has matured into a full dinning establishment catering to New Yorkers and tourist from across the seas.
“Reservations for parties of 6 or more”
34
Bar Pasquale
Bar Pasquale is a restaurant in Little Italy described by visitors as drinks-focused, pizza and italian, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
35
Umbertos Clam House
36
Caffe Venezia
37
La Pecora Bianca
38
Lunella Ristorante
39
Ballato
40
L'Amore
41
Parm
42
Cantiere Hambirreria New York
43
Sant Ambroeus
Best Italian Restaurants in Nearby Neighborhoods
More Restaurants in Little Italy
Looking beyond Little Italy? See the best italian restaurants across all of Manhattan →
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best italian restaurants in Little Italy?
Moodap ranks 43 italian restaurants in Little Italy, Manhattan based on ratings, reviews, and insider tips. Top picks include Torrisi (4.6★). Take the Mood Match quiz to find the perfect one for your vibe.
How many italian restaurants are in Little Italy?
There are 43 italian restaurants currently listed in Little Italy on Moodap, with new spots added regularly.
Are italian restaurants in Little Italy expensive?
Little Italy italian restaurants range from $$ to $$. Use Moodap to filter by budget.
What's the highest rated italian in Little Italy?
Torrisi is one of the highest rated italian restaurants in Little Italy, with a 4.6-star rating. See the full rankings above.
Find Your Perfect Spot in Little Italy
Tell us your mood and we'll match you to the ideal italian spot in 25 seconds.
Take the Mood Match