We're in Testing Mode — play with it, explore, try the Mood Match Quiz. Feedback welcome — use the yellow button. @moodap.nyc
Moodap
14 italian restaurants in Harlem

Best Italian Restaurants in Harlem (2026)

Top-rated italian restaurants in Harlem, Manhattan. Ranked by ratings, reviews, and vibe.

Take the Mood Match

Harlem is home to 14 rated italian restaurants. Cuidado de las piel leads the list with a 5.0-star rating. Prices range from $$ to $$.

1
Cuidado de las piel
★ 5.00$$Indoor/Outdoor2949 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10039
2
Nokka LLC
★ 5.00$$Indoor/Outdoor2319 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10027
3
Crispin's Hell's Kitchen
authentic taste in every dish
★ 4.8185 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor1792 Amsterdam Ave and, W 149th St in, New York, NY 10031
“We are taking online reservations! We recommend making a reservation ahead of time. Book your table today! Did you know we do catering? Whatever your occasion, however big or small, we have the perfect options to choose from.”
4
L'Artista Italian Kitchen & Bar
Experience of Northern Italian Cuisine, Great Wine, Craft Cocktails and Music. We take pride in preparing our food from scratch daily.
★ 4.6274 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor142 Hamilton Pl, New York, NY 10031
“Daniel Schnyder is curating a LIVE, free concert series on Sundays from 5pm to 6pm at L'ARTISTA, featuring some incredible musicians; please sign up for our NEWSLETTER in order to get the concert schedule and information. Due to the seasonal nature of our menus, items and prices subject to change without notice, It is always recommended to call and confirm.”
5
Bono Trattoria
Whether you join us for a brick-oven pie or a leisurely meal, you are joining our family table. It is a table that celebrates the essence of Italy's cuisine, which features the hillsides of Umbria and the coasts of Sicily.
★ 4.6958 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor3658 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
“Ordering online is a quick and easy way to get your food from our restaurant. Indoor and outdoor dining available. Catering available for any occasion.”
6
Briciola Harlem
Briciola Harlem is a restaurant in Harlem described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, cozy interior. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.6230 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor398 W 145th St, New York, NY 10031
7
New One Fabene Pizza
★ 4.50$$Indoor/Outdoor2309 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, New York, NY 10030
8
Trufa Restaurant
Trufa Restaurant is a restaurant in Harlem described by visitors as food-focused, italian and american, cozy interior. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.5510 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor3431 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
“Order Directly from us trufarestaurant.com/menu”
9
Lido Harlem Restaurant
The food is memorably delicious, and the atmosphere is elegant but convivial. Our guests say they feel as if they're at the home of a charming Italian friend.
★ 4.51,754 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor2168 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10026
“There are daily specials, so customers who come three times a weak - and many do - always have something new to discover. Our ingredients are almost all locally sourced and organic, and the poultry are meats are from farms that treat animals humanely.”
10
Fumo Harlem
Fumo Harlem is a restaurant in Harlem described by visitors as italian and seafood, cozy interior, high-energy atmosphere. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.51,895 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor1600 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031
11
Settepani Restaurant
Founded in 1992 by Chef Nino Settepani and his wife Leah Abraham, Settepani started in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, and expanded to Harlem in 1999, bringing together Italian, Sicilian, and Ethiopian culinary traditions.
★ 4.30$$Indoor/Outdoor196 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY 10026
12
Mama Tina's Pizzeria
A quintessential Italian pizzeria in Hamilton Heights, Manhattan, known for classic hand-tossed pies and hearty pasta dishes.
★ 3.8126 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor2649 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10030
“Order the 16-inch pie for pickup at the special price of $11”
13
L'Argot
0142 Hamilton Place
14
Fumo
01600 Amsterdam Avenue

Best Italian Restaurants in Nearby Neighborhoods

East HarlemMorningside HeightsHamilton HeightsSugar Hill

More Restaurants in Harlem

AfricanAmericanAsian/Asian FusionAustralianBBQBagels/PretzelsBakery Products/DessertsBritish

Looking beyond Harlem? See the best italian restaurants across all of Manhattan →

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best italian restaurants in Harlem?

Moodap ranks 14 italian restaurants in Harlem, Manhattan based on ratings, reviews, and insider tips. Top picks include Cuidado de las piel (5.0★). Take the Mood Match quiz to find the perfect one for your vibe.

How many italian restaurants are in Harlem?

There are 14 italian restaurants currently listed in Harlem on Moodap, with new spots added regularly.

Are italian restaurants in Harlem expensive?

Harlem italian restaurants range from $$ to $$. Use Moodap to filter by budget.

What's the highest rated italian in Harlem?

Cuidado de las piel is one of the highest rated italian restaurants in Harlem, with a 5.0-star rating. See the full rankings above.

Find Your Perfect Spot in Harlem

Tell us your mood and we'll match you to the ideal italian spot in 25 seconds.

Take the Mood Match