We're in Testing Mode — play with it, explore, try the Mood Match Quiz. Feedback welcome — use the yellow button. @moodap.nyc
Moodap
15 italian restaurants in Gramercy

Best Italian Restaurants in Gramercy (2026)

Top-rated italian restaurants in Gramercy, Manhattan. Ranked by ratings, reviews, and Moodap editor picks.

Take the Mood Match

Gramercy is home to 15 rated italian restaurants. Borgo leads the list with a 4.4-star rating. Prices range from $$ to $$$.

1
BorgoEditor's Pick
★ 4.40$$Indoor/Outdoor124 E 27th St, New York, NY 10016
2
Audace
Audace is a restaurant in Gramercy described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.90$$Indoor/Outdoor365 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10016
3
Isabelle's Osteria
Isabelle's Osteria is a restaurant in Gramercy described by visitors as italian and seafood, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.71,364 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor245 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10003
“Reservations for the dining room at Isabelles osteria are available 30 days in advance for parties of up to 10 guests exclusively on Open Table and Resy. Isabelles takes walk-ins on a first come, first served basis. We recommend booking a reservation for the dining room.”
4
L'Angeletto
L'Angeletto is a restaurant in Gramercy described by visitors as italian and seafood. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.6217 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor327 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003
5
Carlotto
Carlotto is a restaurant in Gramercy described by visitors as italian and seafood, cozy interior, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.60Indoor/Outdoor100 E 19th St, New York, NY 10003
6
Novitá
Novitá is a restaurant in Gramercy described by visitors as food-focused, italian and seafood, known for excellent service. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.5616 reviews$$$Indoor/Outdoor102 E 22nd St, New York, NY 10010
“Reservations available through opentable.com”
7
Rosemary's East
Featuring expansive indoor and outdoor seating in Stuytown Peter Cooper Village, Rosemarys East brings the warmth and authenticity of our original West Village location to Manhattans East Side. Enjoy our spritz bar, multiple private dining options, and a menu of handmade pastas and sourdough pizzas, crafted with the freshest seasonal ingredients.
★ 4.4933 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor350 1st Ave, New York, NY 10010
“Happy Hour: Indoors Only, Weekdays: 4:00pm - 6:00pm. Multiple private dining options available.”
8
Paul & Jimmy’s Ristorante
Paul & Jimmy’s Ristorante is a restaurant in Gramercy described by visitors as food-focused, italian and seafood, relaxed atmosphere. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.4401 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor123 E 18th St, New York, NY 10003
9
Follia
Follia is a restaurant in Gramercy described by visitors as food-focused, pizza and italian, cozy interior. Based on 10 reviews.
★ 4.30$$Indoor/Outdoor179 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003
“Popular brunch spot — arrive early on weekends”
10
Frank's Trattoria
Classic northern style Italian cuisine, with a well-varied and balanced sort of pasta, chicken, veal, and seafood dishes, as well as all types of pizzas. We have a quiet and calm dining room, together with a pizzeria in the front.
★ 4.2374 reviews$$Indoor/Outdoor371 1st Ave, New York, NY 10010
“We are opened and deliver 7 days a week.”
11
Bravo Pizza
★ 4.10$$Indoor/Outdoor115 E 14th St, New York, NY 10003
“Call and Order in (212) 268-4499. DELIVERY or CARRY OUT options available. Online ordering available.”
12
Rosemary's
0350 1 Avenue
13
Centro Italiano Chirurgia
0$$Indoor/Outdoor247 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010
14
Nonna Dora's
0606 2 Avenue
15
Patrizias of Brooklyn
0462 2 Avenue

Best Italian Restaurants in Nearby Neighborhoods

FlatironKips BayStuyvesant TownMurray Hill

More Restaurants in Gramercy

AfricanAmericanAsian/Asian FusionAustralianBBQBagels/PretzelsBakery Products/DessertsBritish

Looking beyond Gramercy? See the best italian restaurants across all of Manhattan →

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best italian restaurants in Gramercy?

Moodap ranks 15 italian restaurants in Gramercy, Manhattan based on ratings, reviews, and insider tips. Top picks include Borgo (4.4★). Take the Mood Match quiz to find the perfect one for your vibe.

How many italian restaurants are in Gramercy?

There are 15 italian restaurants currently listed in Gramercy on Moodap, with new spots added regularly.

Are italian restaurants in Gramercy expensive?

Gramercy italian restaurants range from $$ to $$$. Use Moodap to filter by budget.

What's the highest rated italian in Gramercy?

Borgo is one of the highest rated italian restaurants in Gramercy, with a 4.4-star rating. See the full rankings above.

Find Your Perfect Spot in Gramercy

Tell us your mood and we'll match you to the ideal italian spot in 25 seconds.

Take the Mood Match