What's the vibe at Make My Cake?

Make My Cake is known for its cozy, warm, charming atmosphere.

How expensive is Make My Cake?

Make My Cake is $ — budget-friendly.

Bakery, Cozy, Warm · $0–15 per person

Make My Cake — Best Cafe in Harlem

Moodap™★★★★★0 reviews

Google★★★★★4.0 · 0 reviews

SAFETY RATING COMING SOON

Address409 W 125th St, New York, NY 10027, New York, NY · Get Directions

Phone(212) 932-0833

Websitemakemycake.com

HoursNot listed

Vibe

CozyWarmCharming

Best Times

AfternoonBrunchHappy Hour

Group Size

AboutAll of our cakes are made to excite your sweet senses. Each mouth-watering flavor is created to put a smile on your face.

Know Before You GoReservations are not available. Order Your Holiday Sweets Today! Cakes, Cheese Cakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Pies & Pastries

Tips From Make My Cake for the Best Experience

Insider secrets straight from the business

Reservations are not available. Order Your Holiday Sweets Today! Cakes, Cheese Cakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Pies & Pastries

Reviews of Make My Cake in Harlem

GPS-verified video reviews from real visitors to Make My Cake

📍 GPS-Verified

Video Reviews

Real reviews from verified visitors. You must be at (or recently visited) this location to leave a review.

📍 GPS VerifiedMust be on-site

🎥 Video OnlyNo fake text reviews

⏰ Time-StampedWithin 24 hours

✅ Real PeopleID verified reviewers

Be the First to Review

Photos of Make My Cake, Harlem

Inside, outside, food, drinks, and atmosphere at Make My Cake

📷Add Photos

📷

Own Make My Cake?

Claim your free profile. Add photos, menu, specials, insider tips, and respond to video reviews.

Free ForeverNo fees, no card

Full ControlMenu, hours, specials

Insider SecretsTips & secret menu

AnalyticsSee your traffic

Claim This Business (Free)

Takes 2 minutes · No fees ever

About Moodap™

Every business on Moodap is listed completely free. No pay-to-play, no fees to rank higher, no algorithm that buries you for not paying. Our platform is supported by one local business ad and one corporate ad per result — that's what keeps it free for every business and every user.

Our mission is to genuinely support small business owners by connecting them with customers who are looking for exactly what they offer. No middleman. No markup. Just real discovery.