Upper West SidePizza
Made In New York Pizza Pizza in Upper West Side
The mood
Casual, lively · good late at night · good for small groups
Tell them Moodap sent you.
More like this in Upper West SidePizza · 4 quick questionsThe story
A budget-friendly pizza restaurant on the Upper West Side. Reviewers single out the pizza, say it is consistent, and describe a loud, buzzing room.
Know before you go
- Vibe
- Casual, Lively, Family Friendly
- Perfect for
- Lively Night Out
- Best times
- Afternoon, Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour, Late Night
- Group size
- Solo, Friends (2-3), Small Group (4-6)
The details at Made In New York Pizza
- How to visit
- Delivery · Takeout · Dine-in · Catering
- Dietary options
- Vegetarian
- Setting
- Indoors and outdoors · Outdoor seating
- Atmosphere
- Cozy · Trendy
- Payment
- Credit cards · Debit cards · Tap to pay
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
What reviewers mention about Made In New York Pizza
Moodap read 10 public reviews of Made In New York Pizza and counted what they talk about.
- Pizza10 of 10
- Reliably good2 of 10
- High energy2 of 10
From the community
A closer look through the eyes of people who have been here.
Every visit has a story.
Be the first to share a video review of Made In New York Pizza. Show the space, your favorite find, or what made the visit special.
Video reviews include a browser-provided location signal. Location is not independently verified.
Not sure this is the one?
Find Your Vibe™. When are you going? I'll find places in Upper West Side that fit how you feel.
Good to know about Made In New York Pizza
Made In New York Pizza is at 421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, on the Upper West Side, Manhattan.
Mon–Thu 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM; Fri–Sat 11:00 AM - 1:00 AM; Sun 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM.
You can call Made In New York Pizza at (646) 484-6200.
Expect about $10–20 per person at Made In New York Pizza.
In the 10 reviews of Made In New York Pizza that Moodap read, the most mentioned are pizza (10), reliably good (2), and high energy (2).
Lively night out.
Yes: delivery, takeout, and catering.
Yes: vegetarian options.
Yes: indoors and outdoors and outdoor seating.
Made In New York Pizza lists: wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Own Made In New York Pizza? This page has no menu, insider tip or booking link yet. Claim this free profile to add what’s missing and to answer video reviews.
Something wrong with this listing?
More in Upper West Side
Places like Made In New York Pizza nearby
Also in Upper West Side
- Future Face & Body MedspaSpa5.0Fun · Social
- Upper West Side Yoga and WellnessYoga Studio5.0Social · Casual
- NaiSnow Tea and Bakery (Columbia University）Bakery5.0$$Cozy · Trendy
- Heidi's Yoga For AllYoga Studio5.0Social · Casual
- Étude 72 GYROTONIC® & Pilates StudioFitness Center5.0Social · Casual
- JEDERM skin atelierSpa5.0Social · Casual
