We're in Testing Mode — play with it, explore, try the Mood Match Quiz. Feedback welcome — use the yellow button. Press Kit. Investors. @moodap.nyc
Moodap
Is this your business?Claim This Profile
Pizza, Casual, Lively · $0–15 per person

Made in New York Pizza — Best Restaurant in Upper West Side

Moodap™★★★★★0 reviews
Google★★★★★4.3 · 255 reviews
SAFETY RATING COMING SOON
Address271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023, New York, NY · Get Directions
Phone(646) 449-8556
Websitemadeinnewyorkpizza.com
HoursNot listed
Vibe
CasualLivelyFamily Friendly
Best Times
AfternoonBrunchDinnerHappy HourLate Night
Group Size
SoloFriends (2-3)Small Group (4-6)
AboutMade in New York Pizza is built on a foundation of fresh, natural ingredients, high-quality cheeses, and that legendary NYC water that gives our dough its signature taste. From Midtown to the West Village to the UWS, we're serving up NY-style pizza so irresistible, you'll find yourself coming back for more – and fast.
Know Before You GoDine in, take out + delivery available at all locations Hand-Tossed Slices, Pies & Squares, Famous Spicy Pepperoni Square, Vodka pie, Garlic knots, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Pepperoni roll
Made in New York Pizza profile

Tips From Made in New York Pizza for the Best Experience

Insider secrets straight from the business

Dine in, take out + delivery available at all locations Hand-Tossed Slices, Pies & Squares, Famous Spicy Pepperoni Square, Vodka pie, Garlic knots, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Pepperoni roll

Reviews of Made in New York Pizza in Upper West Side

GPS-verified video reviews from real visitors to Made in New York Pizza

📍 GPS-Verified

Video Reviews

Real reviews from verified visitors. You must be at (or recently visited) this location to leave a review.

📍 GPS VerifiedMust be on-site
🎥 Video OnlyNo fake text reviews
⏰ Time-StampedWithin 24 hours
✅ Real PeopleID verified reviewers
Be the First to Review

Photos of Made in New York Pizza, Upper West Side

Inside, outside, food, drinks, and atmosphere at Made in New York Pizza

📷Add Photos
📷
📷
📷
📷
📷
📷
📷

What People Are Saying About Made in New York Pizza

igxft
Trending posts and discussions
📷
Check out Made in New York Pizza in Upper West Side! Amazing vibes...
f Facebook
🎬▶ 0:54
Is Made in New York Pizza really the best in Upper West Side? Let's find out...
ig Instagram
🎥▶ 1:22
POV: You finally try Made in New York Pizza in Manhattan
t TikTok
Social feed coming soon — aggregated from across the web

Own Made in New York Pizza?

Claim your free profile. Add photos, menu, specials, insider tips, and respond to video reviews.

Free ForeverNo fees, no card
Full ControlMenu, hours, specials
Insider SecretsTips & secret menu
AnalyticsSee your traffic
Claim This Business (Free)
Takes 2 minutes · No fees ever

More in Upper West Side

Other spots nearby worth a look.

Bar Manje

Restaurants & Dining · 5.0★

West Park NYC Open Mic

Bars & Nightlife · 5.0★

Rito Gelato

Coffee & Casual · 5.0★

US & EG delicious

Restaurants & Dining · 5.0★

Candlestick Pilates

Wellness & Recreation · 5.0★

Super Tacos NYC

Restaurants & Dining · 5.0★

About Moodap™

Every business on Moodap is listed completely free. No pay-to-play, no fees to rank higher, no algorithm that buries you for not paying. Our platform is supported by one local business ad and one corporate ad per result — that's what keeps it free for every business and every user.

Our mission is to genuinely support small business owners by connecting them with customers who are looking for exactly what they offer. No middleman. No markup. Just real discovery.