Halloween edition · Pick your kind of night with Not sure where to go? Try Find Your Vibe™.
Find Your Vibe™

Carnegie HillBar

The Pony Bar Bar in Carnegie Hill

4.5 out of 5, 800 reviews$20–30 per person

The Pony Bar in Carnegie Hill

The mood

Lively, social · good late at night · good for small groups

CallWebsite

Tell them Moodap sent you.

More like this in Carnegie Hill5 quick questions

The story

A mid-priced bar in Carnegie Hill. Reviewers single out the drinks, describe it as calm, and praise the service.

“Since 2009, The Pony Bar has proudly poured only American-brewed beer. From crisp IPAs to bold stouts, every tap celebrates the best of U.S. craft brewing. Pair that with cocktails, snacks, sports on screen, and a welcoming crew — and you've got First Avenue's favorite spot for good times.”
From the venue

Specials & happy hour

Specials and happy hour at The Pony Bar

  • Happy hour

    All day happy hour Monday

    $8 draft beers, draft cocktails, wines and well drinks.

    Mon · 3 PM–12 AM

    From their website · Updated Oct 2026
  • Happy hour

    Happy hour

    $8 draft beers, $8 well drinks and $8 wines.

    Tue–Fri · 4:20 PM–6:20 PM

    From their website · Updated Oct 2026

Know before you go

Vibe
Lively, Social
Perfect for
Drinks, Quiet Hangout
Best times
Afternoon, Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour, Late Night
Group size
Friends (2-3), Small Group (4-6)
Insider tip
Tue–Fri 4:20–6:20PM · $8 Draft Beers · $8 Well Drinks · $8 Wines. All Day Happy Hour Monday!

The details at The Pony Bar

How to visit
Takeout · Dine-in
Setting
Indoors
Atmosphere
Casual · Cozy · Trendy
Payment
Credit cards · Debit cards · Tap to pay
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance · Wheelchair-accessible restroom · Wheelchair-accessible seating

What reviewers mention about The Pony Bar

Moodap read 10 public reviews of The Pony Bar and counted what they talk about.

  • The drinks4 of 10
  • Calm and quiet4 of 10
  • Great service3 of 10

From the community

A closer look through the eyes of people who have been here.

Every visit has a story.

Be the first to share a video review of The Pony Bar. Show the space, your favorite find, or what made the visit special.

Video reviews include a browser-provided location signal. Location is not independently verified.

Not sure this is the one?

Find Your Vibe™. When are you going? I'll find places in Carnegie Hill that fit how you feel.

Good to know about The Pony Bar

Own The Pony Bar? This page has no menu or booking link yet. Claim this free profile to add what’s missing and to answer video reviews.

Something wrong with this listing?

Places like The Pony Bar nearby

Also in Carnegie Hill