Skip to content
Halloween edition · Pick your kind of night with Not sure where to go? Try Find Your Vibe™.

Quiet money. Great food.

Best Bars & Nightlife in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan

5 bars & nightlife in Carnegie Hill, ranked by rating and reviews, with vibes and insider tips.

Carnegie Hill in a line

Old money energy with new restaurant openings

Insider tip

Skip the Madison Ave scene. The side streets have hidden bistros that museum crowds never find.

All Bars & Nightlife in Carnegie Hill

Ranked by rating and how many reviews back it. Open any venue for hours, photos, and reviews.

  • 4.5 out of 5Price level $$

    Since 2009, The Pony Bar has proudly poured only American-brewed beer. From crisp IPAs to bold stouts, every tap celebrates the best of U.S. craft brewing. Pair that with cocktails, snacks, sports on screen, and a welcoming crew — and you've got First Avenue's favorite spot for good times.

    • Lively
    • Social
  • Wine bar

    La Cava

    4.4 out of 5Price level $$$

    Our menu features an exceptional selection of tapas, fresh seafood, and perfectly grilled meats, complemented by an extensive wine list and craft cocktails.

    • Intimate
    • Relaxed
    • Romantic
  • 4.4 out of 5Price level $$

    2nd Floor Bar & Essen is a bar in Carnegie Hill described by visitors as drinks-focused, cozy interior, upscale. Based on 10 reviews.

    • Trendy
    • Upscale
    • Lively
  • 5.0 out of 5, 4 reviews

    Cenizas cigar room is a popular bar in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan. A go-to spot for drinks and good times in the neighborhood.

    • Lively
    • Social
  • 4.3 out of 5Price level $$

    Bluestone Lanes Upper East Side Café is the most unique and interesting location we have created. Located in the heart of Museum Mile, with a 5th Ave address and opposite the E90 th Street entrance to Central Park, this store is housed adjacent to the beautiful historic Church of the Heavenly Rest.

    • Lively
    • Social

Frequently asked questions

What are the best bars in Carnegie Hill?
Ranked by rating and number of reviews, the top bars in Carnegie Hill on Moodap are The Pony Bar (4.5 stars), La Cava (4.4 stars) and 2nd Floor Bar & Essen (4.4 stars). The full list is on this page.
How is the full list of bars in Carnegie Hill ranked?
By star rating, weighted by how many reviews back it: a place with hundreds of strong reviews ranks above a perfect score from a handful. Places with few or no reviews come after well-reviewed ones. Not sure which fits your plans? Find Your Vibe™ picks one for your mood in about 25 seconds.

Find your spot in Carnegie Hill

Answer a few quick questions and Moodap narrows it down to places that fit your mood.

Find Your Vibe™